LP SmartSide vs James Hardie Siding: How They Compare
LP SmartSide and James Hardie siding look alike on a finished house, but they are made of different things. LP SmartSide is engineered wood: wood strands treated with waxes, resins and zinc borate, then pressed into boards. James Hardie is fiber cement: Portland cement, sand, water and cellulose fibers. In short, Hardie is the choice if fire resistance and a non-prorated substrate warranty matter most to you; LP SmartSide is the choice if you want lighter, longer boards and a warranty that names hail. Both take paint, both come primed or prefinished, and both need a careful install to keep water out of the wall.
We are Patriot Roofing and Restoration in Maumelle, and we install and repair all types of siding across Central Arkansas, including engineered wood and fiber cement, under our Arkansas Residential Home Improvement License, 0421461126. We are not paid by either maker, and the product facts below come from LP Building Solutions and James Hardie's own websites, checked November 21, 2026. Where one maker compares itself to the other, we say so, because those are the maker's claims, not ours.
LP SmartSide vs James Hardie at a glance
| LP SmartSide (engineered wood) | James Hardie (fiber cement) | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is made of | Wood strands treated with waxes, resins and zinc borate, with an overlay, per LP | Portland cement, sand, water and cellulose fibers, per Hardie |
| Fire | LP's pages we read make no noncombustible claim; it is a wood-based product | Hardie says it is noncombustible per ASTM E136 and "won't burn or ignite when exposed to a direct flame" |
| Substrate warranty | 50-year prorated limited warranty with a 5-year, 100% labor and material replacement feature, per LP | 30-year non-prorated, transferable substrate limited warranty, per Hardie |
| Prefinished color warranty | 15-year finish warranty on ExpertFinish prefinished products, per LP | 15-year ColorPlus finish limited warranty covering paint and labor, per Hardie |
| Hail | LP says its warranty covers hail damage from hail up to 1.75 inches in diameter, when properly installed and maintained | Hardie's pages we read do not give a hail size |
| Weight and board length | LP says its lap boards are 25 percent longer and up to 39 percent lighter per square foot than fiber cement | Heavier boards that take more labor to cut, carry and hang |
| Rot and pests | Treated to help resist fungal decay and termite damage, per LP | Hardie says it resists moisture and rot and does not appeal to woodpeckers or termites |
Warranties are the makers' documents, not ours, and each has its own conditions. Read the warranty for the exact product on your quote before you sign.
What LP SmartSide does well
LP SmartSide is built to look like painted wood without the soft spots of real wood. LP says every strand is treated with resins, waxes and zinc borate and finished with an overlay, which it calls SmartGuard, to help the boards resist fungal decay and termites.
Weight is LP's big selling point for installers. In its May 11, 2017 release, LP said its lap siding pieces are 25 percent longer and up to 39 percent lighter per square foot than fiber cement. Longer boards mean fewer butt joints on a long wall, and lighter boards are easier to carry up a ladder and hold in place.
LP also put hail in writing. Its warranty page says LP SmartSide resists damage from hail up to 1.75 inches in diameter, and its 5/50 warranty article says the warranty covers that hail damage "when the siding is properly installed and maintained." LP reports that in testing it commissioned at Texas Tech, LP SmartSide lap siding showed no sign of impact from 1.75-inch hail at 81 mph, while the fiber cement sample it tested was dented. That is LP's own test, so weigh it as a maker's claim.
How the LP warranty works: LP describes it as five years of 100% labor and material replacement, then a prorated material warranty out to 50 years, where LP covers a portion of the material cost. LP also says a problem caused by incorrect installation does not void the whole warranty, only coverage for the damage that the install caused, and that you need to contact LP within 30 days of finding an issue and before starting a permanent repair.
The trade-offs: it is still a wood product. LP itself calls moisture "the single most important weather element to threaten a home's siding," which is why the treatment, the paint and the install details matter so much. LP's pages we read do not claim it is noncombustible.
What James Hardie does well
Fiber cement's headline is fire. James Hardie says its siding is noncombustible, verified per ASTM E136, and is used in wall assemblies with 1-hour and 2-hour fire ratings per ASTM E119. Hardie also notes that the fire resistance does not extend to the paint or coatings on top, which can char.
Hardie says its siding resists damage from moisture and rot and holds no appeal for woodpeckers, termites and other pests. It backs its siding, trim and soffit with a 30-year non-prorated, transferable substrate limited warranty, and its factory-painted ColorPlus finish with a 15-year limited warranty covering paint and labor against peeling, cracking and chipping. Non-prorated means the coverage does not shrink each year the way a prorated warranty does, though the term is shorter than LP's 50.
The trade-offs: fiber cement is heavy and hard. It takes more labor to cut, carry and fasten. Boards sold primed have to be painted after they go up, and any paint will need refreshing someday. Hardie says fiber cement costs more than vinyl, and that it generally costs less than brick, synthetic stucco and some wood siding.
Arkansas weather and these two sidings
Central Arkansas walls see long humid summers, heavy rain and spring hail. Hail is where the two makers make different promises: LP names a hail size in its warranty, and the Hardie pages we read do not. Humidity is where the install matters most for either one. The weather barrier behind the siding, the flashing over windows and doors, and the gaps left between the siding and the roof, the ground and the trim are what keep a wall dry. Our guide to hail damage on siding shows what a hit looks like on each material, and our post on fiber cement vs vinyl siding covers the other common choice.
Which siding fits your house?
- Lean toward James Hardie if a noncombustible wall matters to you, or if you want a substrate warranty that is not prorated.
- Lean toward LP SmartSide if you want lighter, longer boards with fewer seams, or a warranty that spells out hail coverage.
- Match the house when you are repairing a few walls. A repair usually stays with the material that is already there, unless you are re-siding whole walls.
- Check your HOA or historic district first. Some neighborhoods set the siding material or look, and some historic districts do not allow artificial siding on historic buildings.
- Read both warranties on the actual products quoted, including what voids coverage and how claims are filed.
How we quote and install siding
Your Specialist measures every wall, walks you through materials and colors, and gives you a written price. We take the old siding off rather than covering it, so the wall can be checked. Soft sheathing or rot is shown to you and priced in writing before it is repaired. New siding, soffit and fascia carry a 5-year Patriot Built Right Guarantee, and siding repairs carry a 365-Day Patriot Built Right Guarantee. That is our workmanship guarantee, separate from the maker's product warranty. If your roof or gutters are also due, they can be done on the same schedule. See our siding services or siding replacement for more.
Frequently asked questions
Is LP SmartSide better than James Hardie?
Neither wins on every point. Hardie is noncombustible and has a 30-year non-prorated substrate warranty. LP SmartSide is lighter, comes in longer boards and has a 50-year prorated warranty that names hail up to 1.75 inches. The better pick depends on what matters most for your house.
Is LP SmartSide real wood?
It is engineered wood: wood strands treated with waxes, resins and zinc borate and pressed into boards with an overlay, per LP. It is not solid lumber.
Does LP SmartSide hold up to hail?
LP says it resists hail up to 1.75 inches in diameter and that its warranty covers that hail damage when the siding is properly installed and maintained. After any storm, we check siding along with the roof.
Does James Hardie siding need to be painted?
Primed boards do, after they are installed. ColorPlus boards come painted from the factory and carry a 15-year finish limited warranty, per Hardie. Any paint will need refreshing eventually.
Does Patriot install LP SmartSide and James Hardie?
We install all types of siding, including engineered wood and fiber cement, and we repair it too. Your Specialist will show you the options that fit your house and give you a written price.
Trying to choose between the two?
We will measure the house, walk you through both materials and put the price in writing. Contact us or call 501.441.2900 to set up a visit.
21-Point Roof Inspection
Your Roofing Specialist checks the roof and attic and gives you a 21-point report with photos of what we find.
Roof Repair Diagnostic Visit
Includes the 21-Point Roof Inspection Report and attic analysis. Patriot Care Club members pay no service fee.