Open 24/7 · phones answered live Licensed, Bonded & Insured · Instant Estimate $0 down financing 501.441.2900

Search patriotroof.net

Can't find it? Call 501.441.2900, open 24/7, or book an inspection.

Book an Inspection

Fiber Cement vs Vinyl Siding: Which Is Better for Your Home?

New cedar board siding and a new plywood soffit being installed on a gable wall, before paint

Fiber cement siding is the tougher, heavier choice: it does not burn, it holds up to moisture and pests, and it can be painted any color, but it is heavier to put up and painted boards need repainting over time. Vinyl siding is the lighter, simpler choice: it never needs paint and the color goes all the way through, but it is a plastic that can crack or dent on a hard hit and it does not carry a fire rating like fiber cement. Neither one is right for every house. The better pick depends on what you want to maintain, how the wall faces the weather and what the rest of the house is made of.

We are Patriot Roofing and Restoration in Maumelle, and we install and repair all types of siding across Central Arkansas under our Arkansas Residential Home Improvement License, 0421461126. Below is how the two compare, using what the makers themselves publish. Product facts come from James Hardie and CertainTeed's own pages, checked November 21, 2026.

Fiber cement vs vinyl siding at a glance

Fiber cement (James Hardie example)Vinyl (CertainTeed example)
What it isCement-based boards, panels and trimVinyl panels
FireHardie says its siding is noncombustible and complies with ASTM E136CertainTeed lists a Class 1(A) fire rating for MainStreet; vinyl is not noncombustible
PaintComes primed for paint or factory finished (ColorPlus)Never needs painting, per CertainTeed
Maker's warranty30-year non-prorated, transferable substrate limited warranty; 15-year ColorPlus finish limited warrantyLifetime limited warranty on Monogram and MainStreet
WeightHeavy boards, more labor to cut and hangLightweight, per CertainTeed
WindNo wind figure on the product pageCertainTeed says Monogram has been tested to wind load pressures up to 210 mph
Moisture and pestsHardie says it resists moisture and holds no appeal for woodpeckers or termitesVinyl does not rot; the wall behind still needs a good water barrier

Warranties are the maker's documents, not ours. Read the actual warranty for the product on your quote, because terms and conditions differ by line and change over time.

What fiber cement does well

Fiber cement looks like painted wood lap siding, and it is stiff enough that the boards stay straight on a long wall. James Hardie says its siding is noncombustible, that "it will not burn," and that it complies with ASTM E136 as a noncombustible cladding. Hardie also notes the fire resistance does not extend to the paint or coatings on top, which can char.

Hardie says its siding resists damage from moisture and holds no appeal for pests like woodpeckers or termites. It backs its siding, trim and soffit with a transferable 30-year, non-prorated substrate limited warranty, and its factory ColorPlus finish with a 15-year limited warranty covering paint and labor against peeling, cracking and chipping. Hardie also says its products are formulated for the climate of each region.

The trade-offs: fiber cement is heavy and hard, so it takes more labor to cut, carry and fasten. Boards sold primed for paint have to be painted after they go up, and any painted finish will need repainting at some point. Joints, butt ends and trim details matter, because water that gets behind any siding ends up in the wall.

What vinyl does well

Vinyl is light, quick to hang and colored all the way through, so a scratch does not show a different color underneath. CertainTeed says its Monogram and MainStreet lines are virtually maintenance free and never need painting, and carries a lifetime limited warranty on both. CertainTeed says Monogram's RigidForm 210 technology has been tested to withstand wind load pressures up to 210 mph, and lists a Class 1(A) fire rating for MainStreet.

The trade-offs: vinyl is a plastic. It is hung so it can move as it heats and cools, which is why a vinyl wall that was nailed too tight can ripple. A hard impact, such as large hail, a mower-thrown rock or a ladder, can crack or punch through a panel. A damaged panel can usually be replaced on its own, if a match is still made. Vinyl can also warp or melt near a grill or other strong heat, so it is not the choice for a wall that needs to resist fire.

Arkansas weather and the two sidings

Central Arkansas walls see summer heat and humidity, heavy rain and spring hail. Siding takes the same storm your roof does, and it is the part of the house most often missed after a storm. Our guide to hail damage on siding shows what a hit looks like on each material: vinyl tends to crack, split or punch through, and fiber cement is more resistant, per LP Building Solutions, but can show chipped paint or cracked edges. Either way, the important question is whether water can now get behind the wall.

Humidity is the other half. Whatever siding you choose, the weather barrier behind it, the flashing over windows and doors and the gap between siding and the roof or ground are what keep the wall dry. A good install of either material beats a careless install of the other.

Which siding fits your house?

  • Choose fiber cement if you want a painted-wood look, a noncombustible wall, a long non-prorated substrate warranty, and you are fine repainting primed boards down the road.
  • Choose vinyl if you want no painting, lighter weight, simple panel-by-panel repairs, and a lower-maintenance wall.
  • Matching what is already there often decides it. A repair on a vinyl house is usually vinyl, and a fiber cement house usually stays fiber cement, unless you are re-siding whole walls.
  • Check your HOA before choosing. Some neighborhoods set the siding material or look.

For how long each material tends to last, see how long new siding lasts.

How we quote and install siding

Your Specialist measures every wall, walks you through material and color, and gives you a written price. We take the old siding off rather than covering it, so the wall can be checked. Any soft sheathing or rot is shown to you and priced in writing before it is fixed. New siding, soffit and fascia carry a 5-year Patriot Built Right Guarantee, and siding repairs carry a 365-Day Patriot Built Right Guarantee. If your roof or gutters are also due, they can be done on the same schedule. See our siding services for the full list.

Frequently asked questions

Is fiber cement siding better than vinyl?

It is better for fire resistance and for a painted-wood look, and James Hardie backs its boards with a 30-year non-prorated substrate warranty. Vinyl is better if you never want to paint and want lighter, simpler repairs. Neither wins on every point.

Does fiber cement siding need to be painted?

Primed boards do, after they are installed. Factory-finished boards such as Hardie's ColorPlus come painted and carry their own 15-year finish limited warranty. Any paint will need refreshing eventually.

Does vinyl siding hold up to hail?

It can crack, split or break on a hard hit. Damaged panels can often be replaced one at a time if a match is available. After a storm, we check siding along with the roof.

Which siding does Patriot install?

We install all types of siding, including vinyl and fiber cement, and we repair it too. Your Specialist will show you the options that fit your house and give you a written price.

Can I mix fiber cement and vinyl on one house?

Yes, some homes use one on the main walls and another on gables or accents. The key is clean trim and flashing where the two meet.

Thinking about new siding?

We will measure the house, show you both materials side by side and put the price in writing. Contact us or call 501.441.2900 to set up a visit.

Inspection

21-Point Roof Inspection

Your Roofing Specialist checks the roof and attic and gives you a 21-point report with photos of what we find.

$79.99

Roof Repair Diagnostic Visit

Includes the 21-Point Roof Inspection Report and attic analysis. Patriot Care Club members pay no service fee.

Book it now

Have No Fear, Patriot Is Here!

Call any time. Our phones are answered live 24/7.

Financing available, with approved credit

$0 down, 0% financing for 12 months, or payments of about $176 a month on $15,000 at 12.99% APR for 240 months. Soft credit check, approval in as little as 60 seconds.

Check My Options

Financing is with approved credit. Promotional rates and terms are not guaranteed and can change at any time. Payment example: $15,000 financed with $0 down at 12.99% APR for 240 months is 240 monthly payments of $175.63. 0% financing for 12 months is a promotional offer from the lender; the terms that apply after the promotional period are set by the lender. We work with more than one lending partner, and the rates and terms you are offered are set by the lender you are approved with, not by Patriot Roofing and Restoration. All rates and terms are presented to you in writing before you sign anything.

Instant Estimate