Types of Roof Shingles: A Guide for Arkansas Homeowners
There are two big families of roof shingles. The first is asphalt shingles, which come in three styles: 3-tab (strip) shingles, architectural (also called laminated or dimensional) shingles, and luxury or designer shingles, and any of them can also be built to an impact rating. The second is shingles made from other materials: wood shingles and shakes, natural slate, synthetic (polymer) shingles that imitate slate or wood, and metal shingles. Asphalt is the most common roof in Central Arkansas, and the architectural shingle is where Patriot Roofing and Restoration starts every shingle roof. Below is what each type is, how they differ, and which ones we install.
The quick comparison
| Shingle type | What it is | Does Patriot install it new? |
|---|---|---|
| 3-tab (strip) asphalt | A single flat layer with cutouts that make three tabs | No; we repair existing 3-tab roofs |
| Architectural (laminated) asphalt | Two or more layers fused together for a thicker, dimensional look | Yes, our Economy package starts here |
| Luxury (designer) asphalt | Heavier laminated shingles styled to look like shake or slate | On request, quoted in writing |
| Impact-rated asphalt (Class 3 or Class 4) | Architectural shingles tested for hail under UL 2218 | Yes, our Shield and Shield Plus packages |
| Wood shingles and shakes | Sawn shingles or split shakes, often cedar | Not part of our lineup |
| Natural slate | Quarried stone | Not part of our lineup |
| Synthetic (composite) shingles | Polymer products made to look like slate or wood | No |
| Metal shingles | Metal formed to look like shingles, shake or tile | No; our metal roofs are panels (Armor) and standing seam |
Asphalt shingles: the three styles
An asphalt shingle is a fiberglass mat coated with asphalt and topped with mineral granules. The National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA) describes fiberglass shingles that way and notes that most of them carry a Class A fire rating, the highest. What changes from one style to the next is how the shingle is cut and layered.
3-tab (strip) shingles
The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA) groups these as strip shingles: long, narrow shingles about three times as long as they are wide, sorted by how many cutouts or tabs they have, with the three-tab style the most common. CertainTeed calls strip shingles "the original and most basic asphalt shingles," a single layer with a flat look, and says they generally weigh and cost less than other asphalt shingles.
Plenty of older Arkansas homes still have 3-tab roofs. We repair them, but we do not install new 3-tab roofs. When one needs replacing, we replace it with architectural or impact-rated shingles, which stand up better to Arkansas wind and hail. Our post on architectural vs 3-tab shingles goes through that comparison in detail.
Architectural (laminated or dimensional) shingles
ARMA describes laminated shingles as having more than one tab layer for added thickness, and notes they are also called three-dimensional or architectural shingles. CertainTeed says they are made of two or more layers of asphalt fused together, which gives the thicker, shadowed look many people associate with a newer roof, and that they are typically heavier than strip shingles.
This is the standard shingle on most homes we replace. Our Economy package uses a standard architectural shingle (not impact rated) and carries a 5-year Patriot Leak Free Guarantee.
Luxury (designer) shingles
CertainTeed describes luxury shingles as the highest grade of laminated shingle: heavier, with more color variation and depth, made to give the most realistic look of wood shake or quarried slate in an asphalt product. Not every maker uses the same names for this tier, so compare the actual product, not the label. Patriot installs just about any shingle a customer needs, so if you want a designer look, we will price that product in writing. Our guide to luxury asphalt shingles covers when they are worth it.
Impact-rated shingles: a rating, not a separate style
"Impact-resistant" describes how a shingle performed in a hail test, not how it looks. Under UL 2218, shingles are rated Class 1 through Class 4, and Class 4 is the highest rating a shingle can earn. In Central Arkansas, where hail is a regular part of spring, this rating is often the most important choice you make.
- Shield package: a Class 3 impact-rated architectural shingle, rated for hail up to 1-3/4 inches, with a 10-year Patriot Leak Free Guarantee.
- Shield Plus package: a Class 4 impact-rated shingle (UL 2218), rated for hail up to 2 inches, with a 15-year Patriot Leak Free Guarantee. A Class 4 roof may qualify you for a homeowners insurance discount; discounts vary by insurer, so confirm with your agent.
Atlas is our primary shingle line. Among the Atlas lines we install, StormMaster Shake and Pinnacle Impact are Class 4, and Pinnacle Pristine and Pinnacle Sun are Class 3. 3M Scotchgard Protector is factory applied to the Atlas lines we install to resist the black algae streaks common on older roofs in a humid state like ours.
Shingles made from other materials
Wood shingles and shakes
NRCA explains that wood shingles and shakes are made from cedar, redwood, Southern pine and other woods. Shingles are sawn by machine; shakes are split and have a rougher surface. Fire is the main concern: NRCA notes that many carry only a Class C fire rating or none, some factory-treated products reach Class A, and some local codes limit wood roofing for that reason. Patriot does not offer wood roofs. If you like the look, an architectural or designer asphalt shingle styled like shake is the usual alternative.
Natural slate
NRCA calls slate "virtually indestructible" and more expensive than other roofing materials, and says installing it takes specialized skill and experience. Color and grade depend on the quarry. Slate is also heavy, so it is rarely a simple swap for an asphalt roof. It is not part of Patriot's lineup.
Synthetic (composite) shingles
Synthetic shingles are polymer products made to imitate slate or wood. NRCA cautions that they do not necessarily have the same properties as the materials they imitate and recommends researching any specific synthetic product before choosing it. The word "composite" causes a lot of confusion, because "composition shingles" is also an old name for asphalt shingles. Our post on composite shingles sorts out the two meanings. Patriot does not install synthetic composite shingles.
Metal shingles
According to NRCA, metal roofing comes as panels or as shingles, metal shingles are designed to look like wood shakes, shingles or tile, and some carry a Class A fire rating. Patriot does not install metal shingles or stone-coated steel. Our metal roofs are panel systems: Armor, a 26-gauge PBR steel panel roof, Class A fire rated, rated for hail up to 2 inches and backed by a 15-year Patriot Leak Free Guarantee, and standing seam metal, priced in writing after we measure your roof. Metal roofs commonly last 40 to 70 years.
Clay and concrete tile are close cousins of shingles. NRCA describes tile as durable but heavy, so a home switching from a lighter roof to tile needs its structure checked for the added load. We do not install tile.
Which type makes sense for a Central Arkansas home?
- On a budget, staying a few years: a standard architectural shingle (Economy) is a sound, complete roof.
- Worried about hail: an impact-rated shingle. Class 3 (Shield) is a step up; Class 4 (Shield Plus) is the highest rating and may earn an insurance discount.
- Want the look of shake or slate: a designer asphalt shingle gives the look without the weight and upkeep of the real material.
- Staying long term and done with storm claims: compare an impact-rated shingle with a metal panel roof. Plan on 15 to 20 years from an asphalt shingle roof in Arkansas, against 40 to 70 for metal.
Whatever you choose, the shingle is only one layer. Every Patriot replacement includes a full tear-off to the decking, starter shingles, synthetic underlayment, ice and water shield in the valleys, drip edge on the full perimeter, flashing and ventilation. See all four packages side by side on our asphalt shingle roofing page and our roof types page.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most common type of roof shingle?
Asphalt shingles, and among them architectural (laminated) shingles. ARMA describes laminated shingles as popular with builders, roofing contractors and homebuyers, and they are what we install on most Central Arkansas homes.
Are architectural shingles the same as dimensional or laminated shingles?
Yes. Architectural, dimensional and laminated all describe the same kind of asphalt shingle: two or more layers bonded together for extra thickness and a textured look.
Can I still get a new 3-tab roof?
Some roofers still install 3-tab shingles, but Patriot does not. We repair existing 3-tab roofs and replace them with architectural or impact-rated shingles.
Do you only install Atlas shingles?
No. Atlas is our primary line and the one we recommend, but we install just about any shingle brand a customer needs, for example to meet HOA rules or to match another part of the roof. The extended Atlas Signature Select system warranty applies to Atlas systems; other brands carry their own manufacturer warranty.
Which shingle is best for hail?
A shingle with a Class 4 rating under UL 2218, the highest impact rating a shingle can earn. No shingle is hail-proof, but a Class 4 shingle has passed the toughest version of the test.
Not sure what is on your roof now?
We can tell you what type of shingle you have, how it is holding up and what your options are. Replacement inspections are free: book a free storm or replacement inspection on our contact page or call 501.441.2900.
21-Point Roof Inspection
Your Roofing Specialist checks the roof and attic and gives you a 21-point report with photos of what we find.
Roof Repair Diagnostic Visit
Includes the 21-Point Roof Inspection Report and attic analysis. Patriot Care Club members pay no service fee.